Movie Review: ‘The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping’ Matches Familiar Beats with Emotional Impact


Director: Francis Lawrence
Writers: Bill Ray, Michael Lesslie
Stars: Joseph Zada, Mckenna Grace, Whitney Peak, Ralph Fiennes

Synopsis: Revisit the world of Panem 24 years before the events of The Hunger Games, starting on the morning of the reaping of the 50th Hunger Games, also known as the Second Quarter Quell.


The Hunger Games, both as a film franchise and a book series (all written by author Suzanne Collins), is a fascinating specimen of our culture not just because of the cultural phenomenon across the world that it stirred but also how its relevance has lasted even nearly two decades after the first book’s release. Yes, the endless craze of YA dystopian books and films have continued to ripple throughout the Hollywood landscape but many of those franchises have died out. Hunger Games has not only remained as popular as ever, in spite of the ups and downs of the film series, but has also maintained an increasingly obvious parallel to many aspects of today’s world as the dystopia we see on the screen can bleed more into reality than we’d ever like. With Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping, the franchise has now firmly segmented its longevity into the fruitful but weary territory that is prequels following 2023’s Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes, and, for better or worse, Sunrise on the Reaping retains all of the series growing pains and powerful uproars on the importance of resilience against the manipulative nature of authoritarianism. 

Sunrise on the Reaping falls victim to much of what you’d expect out of a sixth entry in a franchise, with repeating well-worn plot beats and thematics being its main hamper, but the film’s deeper focus on Haymitch and his struggles to remain a spark within all of the endless hopelessness around him sells the film in a nature that’s amongst some of the most impactful emotional territory of the series. Long story short, it’s a classic cavalcade of long running franchise pros and cons, but the pros are just high enough to make this latest entry worth it. 

Sunrise on the Reaping’s events take place 24 years before the events of the very first Hunger Games movie as we are introduced to the early life of fan favorite character, Haymitch Abernathy (Joseph Zada) and his family celebrating his 16th birthday in District 12. Haymitch is spending the couple hours of precious time left for his birthday with the love of his life, Lenore Dove Baird (Whitney Peak), but the two of them are only delaying the inevitable in Panem as yet another reaping ceremony is set to commence for the 50th Hunger Games. Only this time, for the special occasion, the Second Quarter Quell is set to commence where twice the number of tributes are set to participate (two girls and boys instead of one of each). 

As Drusilla Sickle (Glenn Close) draws the names of the tributes to select, Haymitch is initially not selected but gets himself into a skirmish with the Peacekeepers once they put Lenore in danger, leading to Drusilla, thanks to the convincing of Plutarch Hevansbee (Jesse Plemons), to make Haymitch take part as a tribute in the games rather than killing him and Lenore. Haymitch will now have to work alongside fellow district 12 tributes Maysille Donner (Mckenna Grace), Wyatt Callow (Ben Wang), and extremely young Louella McCoy (Molly McCann) as he fights for his life in the games, but also President Snow’s (Ralph Fiennes) attempts to stomp him out for daring to rise up against pure complicity. 

It is an inherent miracle in itself that the Hunger Games franchise has managed to still carry over so much emotional resonance even with the film covering much of the same bases in terms of story mechanics, but that doesn’t mean this latest entry doesn’t fall victim to natural issues when extending a series like this that already its technical conclusion a decade ago. Much of Sunrise of the Reaping, especially its first half, dips into retread territory; to the point where moments of the more emotional beats feel as stretched out as possible for there to remain justification for this prequel’s existence. Since the emotional core of this film resides in a well-known character that has such a tragic but soulful spirit to him, this is less of a problem than it normally would be, but it doesn’t prevent the film from becoming bloated when we go through beats or thematics we’ve seen before like the train ride to the capital, or the chariot ceremony especially in such a lengthy runtime. 

There also exists an unfortunate mark of many prequels  which is the very on-the-nose winks and nods to future characters, connection, and events that will be important to the franchise’s future, call it pulling a Solo: A Star Wars Story if you will. Some moments or charters are less egregious than others like the interpretations of Maya Hawke’s Wiress and Kelvin Harrison Jr. ‘s Beetee who provides the film with enough of their own heft to know why they act the way they do in future events. Other moments can verge on pure absurdity, where writers Bill Ray and Michael Lesslie might as well be nudging your shoulder towards the future of District 12’s future rebellion leader Katniss Everdeen and how her parents interact with Haymitch in this film in a way that can become particularly eye-roll worthy in the film’s references.  

Amidst all the franchise baggage however, there never ceases to exist an emotional palatability to both Haymitch’s relentless heartache as a character of tragic anguish and the enraging cruelty of the games and their master at its center. The showcasing of what The Capital is willing to do in this film specifically to bend the narrative to their whim is particularly frightening in ways that are, of course, not that far off from real life occurrences or the suffering for entertainment threads of captivation found in things like Amazon Prime’s Beast Games (yes, a real Mr. Beast now 3 season show). We witness The Capital often twist words that they recorded Haymitch say in the past or cut the feed to their broadcast to make things always seem like they’re going smoothly or truly punish Haymitch and all those around him for even daring to take a remote stand against Snow’s grip of pure tyranny. Yes, these aspects can also reside in commentary of the franchise we’ve seen before, but they take on a bit more of a devastating nature because of how much this world throws at Haymitch. 

Haymitch suffers so much at the hands of the capital, ripping truly everything from him just to make an example out of what happens to those that even slightly spark a flame of resistance and it leads to slightly predictable but shattering turmoil near the film’s conclusion. More importantly however, the film never forgets the importance of being able to start the flame of resistance against the suffocating oppression of fascist manipulation. Even in the wake of tremendous loss, it’s important to never submit or be complicit within the face of ideals we don’t stand for, even if the road to actual change is a long one. Zada manages to mostly channel the emotional honesty that young Haymitch demands from him at nearly every turn, and although his performance can tend to lean more into a basic best impression of Woody Harrelson, he spurs enough catharsis surrounding Haymitch’s pain to make the performance worthwhile. 

As for the games and the setting of Panem itself, Francis Lawrence continues to find new layers to showcase how the concept of the games have evolved throughout its many eras, especially in these prequels. The inherent nature of the games are as thrilling as ever, but Lawrence makes great use of the 50th games flowery setting, with production designer Uli Hanisch contrasting the inherent beauties of the environment with the harsh brutalities of the games they’re taking place in. It isn’t flawless, as much of the more CGI centric set piecesor shots surrounding animal attacks are a bit garish and rough around the edges but still remain riveting with an escape from an exploding volcano being the set piece highlight here.

The ensemble here also doesn’t have a weak link, as everyone embodies the well-known presence of their character in the franchise or adds slight new shades to them. Kiearan Culkin and Elle Fanning embody the spirit of Caesar Flickerman and Effie Trinket respectively, even as they fit the more comedic sensibilities that are present, while Fiennes makes the icy cold and calculated demeanor of Snow impactful, even in limited screentime. Plemons is the main standout from the cast members portraying well known characters however, as he not only captures Philip Seymour Hoffman’s role, but adds more interiority for the reasoning of why Heavensbee steps between the lines of capital and rebellion. 

The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping has many of the hallmarks found within a franchise wear thin, with reduxing and the stretching out of overly familiar beats but the main culprit at hand, and yet the film still remains powerful at its conclusion because it never forgets the importance of resistance against oppression that exist in its center. Franchise fatigue exists in spades here, but so does a genuine emotional palpability that is stirred from the exploration of both tragedy and revolution surrounding its lead character making for a frustrating but still impactful experience by the time its credits roll.

Grade: C+

Similar Articles

Comments

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

SPONSOR

spot_img

SUBSCRIBE

spot_img

FOLLOW US

1,900FansLike
1,101FollowersFollow
19,997FollowersFollow
5,480SubscribersSubscribe
Advertisment

MOST POPULAR