Movie Review: ‘Elsinore’ is a Glorious Reminder of the Power of Art


Director: Simon Stone
Writer: Stephen Beresford
Stars: Andrew Scott, Olivia Colman, Billie Piper

Synopsis: A powerful, deeply moving and inspiring story of the actor Ian Charleson who faced incredible odds while preparing to give the performance of his life in Hamlet at the National Theatre in London


“Remember me.”

We will all die, some of us in old age, and some sadly young. But all of us want to be remembered. This is the glory of art, it helps us remember both greatness and those that were forgotten. Likely if you asked a random person, “Who is Ian Charleson,” you would be met with confusion and a lack of awareness. Sure, those who are in tune with the world of theater or queer history might perk up, but they are the exception and not the rule. Great art introduces us to stories that are worthy of remembrance. Elsinore is that type of film, one that grabs a hold of you and clutches you until you feel every drop of emotion with crystal clear clarity. You need not be a lover of Shakespeare in general, or “Hamlet” in particular to be swept away.

Elsinore is the story, inspired by reality, of Charleson, who, while suffering from AIDS, starred in 18 performances (though some accounts claim 24) of “Hamlet” at the National Theatre in London in 1989. Charleson took over the role after Daniel Day-Lewis famously walked off stage in the middle of a scene, never to return to that play or any other stage production. This is where the film begins, and quickly transitions to Charleson (Andrew Scott), spending time with his best friend, Patsy (Billie Piper) and her daughter, Alice (Sadie Soverall). Scott effortlessly allows us in to know Charleson off-stage before he ever becomes Hamlet. This is the crux of the film, as otherwise it simply becomes Andrew Scott as Hamlet (which would also be amazing, for the record).

There are simply not enough superlatives in the English language to accurately describe the greatness of Andrew Scott in Elsinore. This is no surprise, especially given his work in All of Us Strangers, but he is able to, without being excessive, portray nearly every level of humanity encased in a single person. He is able to grasp onto the silence as much as his extensive monologues. Within minutes, he ceases to be Andrew Scott and purely embodies Ian Charleson. Every single interaction is genuine and imperfectly human. Depending on the what the film calls for, he is heartbreaking, funny, romantic, or crumbling in front of our eyes. This is quite simply a masterclass in acting and one of the best performances of this year, or any year.

The film allows him to spend time with chosen family, lovers, friends, and his birth family and it never feels forced. The pacing, thanks to director Simon Stone and editor Valerio Bonelli, has us experience everything as it was meant to be. Unlike many films of its ilk, there are no sequences in which a contrivance is obviously invented to pull our strings. There are numerous opportunities where the screenplay, from Stephen Beresford, could have given Charleson a simple scene of closure, but he opts for realism. This is absolutely to the film’s advantage, especially in scenes involving his father, Jack (Peter Mullan). There is closure, but it happens without Scott on screen, which allows Mullan to experience a moment of both love and regret that will live in your memory long after the film ends.

As Charleson is obviously ill, he is recommended to a doctor by a costumer who, being gay, notices his small lesion because he is “family.” When he meets the doctor, Margaret Johnson (Olivia Colman), we are given the gift of numerous back-and-forths between Colman and Scott. The relationship that is built, almost immediately, by two expert performers is necessary not only to the truth of this story, but to the film’s thesis: Art lives forever. Survival is not enough, we need joy.

As the film grows, and he gets sicker, there is little doubt as to how Charleson will fare in the end. But that is not the story of Elsinore. After all, “the play’s the thing.” And when you have Andrew Scott in a film about performing “Hamlet,” you are going to damn well perform “Hamlet.” Elsinore intercuts his life and death on stage, with the same off stage. This technique, though well-worn, is particularly effective here, as it gives Scott ample opportunity to show his range. Many of us know the lines of “Hamlet.” It is, after all, one of the great pieces of art in history. Scott manages to make it his own and reminds us that he is not only a great actor, but one of the few who is able to easily make Shakespeare accessible to the modern ear. When he is spouting the Bard’s famous lines, we see it, feel it, hear it, and darn near touch it. This, paired with his almost uncomfortably raw portrayal of a man suffering from AIDS, provides even more proof that he is one of the best actors working in film today. There is an argument in which you could remove the words “one of the” from that previous sentence.

Elsinore is not quite a one-man show, but the film crumbles without Andrew Scott. This is a portrayal that demands to be remembered, and does the dual duty of allowing us to remember the gifts given by Ian Charleson and Margaret Johnson. But it is so much more than that. Elsinore is a celebration of art, artists, a lost generation of queer men, and the people (mostly women) that supported them and held them while they suffered, ignored by governments and “moral crusaders” the world over. As Scott performs in the film, “I see the imminent death of 20,000 men who for a fantasy and trick of fame go to their graves like beds.” 

Elsinore and the art it celebrates helps us remember those who gave their art, their glory, their quality, their joy, even their lives. In a time where AI is the talk of Hollywood, Elsinore is a blessing as it reminds us that artists are the soul of our culture, and we would be nothing without the art they create.

Grade: A

Similar Articles

Comments

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

SPONSOR

spot_img

SUBSCRIBE

spot_img

FOLLOW US

1,900FansLike
1,101FollowersFollow
19,997FollowersFollow
5,480SubscribersSubscribe
Advertisment

MOST POPULAR