Chasing The Gold: Can [REDACTED] See an Oscar?

You Can See Everything has quickly become one of the most talked-about and discussed documentaries of the year, maybe of all time. Directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, the documentary is unlike traditional films in this genre, taking a more ambiguous, weird, and creative approach that refuses to see anything in black and white and creates unique ways to tell its story. One of those unique approaches is incorporating an actress, labeled [REDACTED] in many early pieces on the film, who is both part of the storytelling process and the story itself.

Spoilers beware: that actress is, of course, Amanda Seyfried, the same woman who won an Emmy for her portrayal of Holmes in the Hulu series, The Dropout. In You Can See Everything, Fielder shows The Dropout to Holmes, prompting a visceral reaction as the real Holmes watches the fictional Holmes. After she goes to prison, Fielder reaches out to Seyfried and shows her footage he got of Holmes before her trip. He not only includes Seyfried in the non-fiction portion of the film, but he also uses the same woman who won an award for playing Holmes to portray her in certain reenactments. These reenactments let the audience see moments between Fielder and Holmes that couldn’t be captured on camera, and while we will never know whether the reenactments are fictional, Seyfried’s committed, heartbreaking performance stays true. Her performance both as herself and in the reenactments has propelled her into the Best Supporting Actress race. Seyfried has a history with the category; she was nominated for Best Supporting Actress for Mank in 2021, but her work here could earn her not only a nomination but also her first win.

However, the glaring question is whether Seyfried can get in for THIS film. Unconventional films have been nominated before, such as James Whitmore, who was nominated for Best Actor for a live recording of his one-man stage play as Harry Truman in Give ‘em Hell, Harry!. Or Maria Bakalova, who was nominated for Best Supporting Actress for her performance as Tutar Sagdiyev in the mockumentary Borat Subsequent Moviefilm. In Seyfried’s case, even if the film is an unconventional Oscar player, her role would be unlike anything ever seen at the Oscars.

It makes sense that a traditional documentary has not received an acting nomination, because, in large part, the actor in question is just a subject playing themselves. At the same time, documentaries can address “characters”; they’re not fictional renderings but real-world tellings. The eligibility requirements and rules set in place by the Academy don’t technically have a rule against this; it’s more of a blanket statement in their official rules that says, “The Actors Branch Executive Committee shall have the right and responsibility to resolve all questions of eligibility, rules, and the designation of award recipients.” Handling the situation with Amanda Seyfried will most certainly raise questions: will the Academy question the full performance, or just the reenactments with her as Holmes? It seems A24 may have gotten out early on this one to push her candidacy by crediting her as Elizabeth Holmes. By doing so, A24 highlights the performance over the self, which gives her a fighting chance at the nomination, even if it still seems like an uphill battle. Let’s assume Seyfried clears that hurdle and the Academy deems her eligible; how far can she go?

This year’s Supporting Actress candidates are more up in the air than they have been in some time. Last year’s race might have been a surprise when Amy Madigan won for her villainous turn in Weapons, but for a long time it had narrowed to a few people who could win and a strong crop of nominees. One thing Madigan had over other nominees wasn’t just the power of the performance, but its placement in the film. Last year, it felt like the race was coming down to Teyana Taylor for One Battle After Another and Madigan; Taylor had passion in her performance, including the Golden Globe win, but it was entirely in the film’s first act. Once the movie reached act two, Taylor was absent for the rest of the film. For Madigan, she wasn’t introduced until partway through the second act and remained a presence until the end. A similar situation happened between Jamie Lee Curtis and Angela Bassett in 2022. Curtis had a strong presence throughout Everything Everywhere All at Once, with her most emotional scenes coming near the end.

In contrast, Bassett’s strong performance ended around an hour into the movie, leaving the audience without her for over an hour. Of course, in this scenario, Everything Everywhere All at Once was a juggernaut of a film, but last year, Weapons received only one nomination, which happened to be Madigan’s win. That doesn’t mean placement in the film is the biggest indicator of who will win this award. Still, in terms of recent success, your performance must be something the audience leaves with as a strong point, not something the rest of the film can overlook. This bodes well for Seyfried, as she was introduced after the first act and had a strong presence throughout the film, and her most emotional and impactful scenes, such as Holmes speaking to Fielder, come at the end of the film. What audiences will remember most won’t be Seyfried as herself, but as Holmes, and for that, I think she has a chance not only to be nominated, but to win this award as well.

While this year’s Supporting Actress category may not be as loaded as in past years, it creates an open race anyone can take. One of those actresses is Anne Hathaway for her performance as Penelope in The Odyssey. Hathaway won this award in 2013 for Les Misérables, but hasn’t earned another nomination since. She is having one helluva 2026, though, with five films releasing this year: three are certified fresh on Rotten Tomatoes, one is fresh (meaning the score fell between 60% and 75%), and only one ended up with a rotten rating. She has been everywhere from indies to legacy sequels to epics, and her films have crossed $2.6 billion worldwide. While Nolan, outside of Oppenheimer, isn’t known for getting his actors nominations, Hathaway has been a mainstay in the film world this year and is aiming for her second Oscar win.

Up until this year, an actor was only able to be nominated for a category once; this hasn’t stopped actors from being nominated twice at the same awards show, but has created category fraud, as some performers campaigned what seemed to be a leading role in the supporting category to try to earn a second nomination – think Jamie Foxx, who was nominated and won Best Actor for Ray and was nominated for Best Supporting Actor for Collateral. I doubt the Academy knew this specific rule change would have so much effect this early, but alas, we have an actress looking to make history with two nominations in one category. This actress is, of course, Penélope Cruz, who is in the race for both The Invite and La Bola Negra. Her two films couldn’t be more different: The Invite is a small-scale indie fighting for a shot, and La Bola Negra is more epic in scope and an early frontrunner for Best Picture. Nevertheless, the actress has delivered strong performances in both films and seems to be in a good place to make history at the Oscars.

There are a few different ways to go for the fifth and final spot. For starters, Samantha Morton shows up for a small portion of The Odyssey but steals her few scenes, making her moments on screen some of the best in the entire film. Then there’s Sandra Hüller, who is in competition for Project Hail Mary. Hüller’s performance might be more subdued and understated than others on this list, but it’s not a stretch to say her presence is felt throughout, drawing the audience in and making them feel for her even through the tough decisions. Andrew Scott’s performance in Elsinore might propel the film further than it could have dreamed; is there a chance Olivia Colman could join him? However, for the last spot, I am going with Tao Okamoto. The actress who stars alongside Virginie Efira in Ryusuke Hamaguchi’s All of a Sudden co-won Best Actress at the Cannes Film Festival with Efira. The two of them could be a duo when it comes to nominations, and I still have Efira in, so I feel obligated to think Okamoto will join her as well.

Predicted Nominees:

  1. Amanda Seyfried (You Can See Everything)
  2. Anne Hathaway (The Odyssey)
  3. Penelope Cruz (The Invite)
  4. Penelope Cruz (La Bola Negra)
  5. Tao Okamoto (All of a Sudden)

Next Up:

  1. Samantha Morton (The Odyssey)
  2. Mariana di Girolamo (Wild Horse Nine)
  3. Sandra Huller (Project Hail Mary)
  4. Olivia Colman (Elsinore)
  5. Merritt Wever (Primetime)
Jacob Throneberry
Jacob Throneberry
Jacob Throneberry has always had a love of film and a desire to write. He is pursuing his Master's Degree at the University of North Carolina - Wilmington and is a member of the North Carolina Film Critics Association. He is on X (formerly Twitter) and Letterboxd at @jtberry97.

Similar Articles

Comments

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

SPONSOR

spot_img

SUBSCRIBE

spot_img

FOLLOW US

1,900FansLike
1,101FollowersFollow
19,997FollowersFollow
5,480SubscribersSubscribe
Advertisment

MOST POPULAR