Directors: Kyle Lloyd Arpke
Synopsis: Egos, money, and science intersect in a modern American parable that follows the king of the dinosaurs and those who uncover its remains.
Scientists are on a mission to save the world one dinosaur at a time. Or so Kyle Lloyd Arpke’s documentary The New Extinction wants us to think. It’s our faith in science and scientists that will set us free and create a safer future for our children and their children. But how can we achieve that in an ever-shifting world where real scientists are not rewarded, unfairly pushed to the background, and underfunded while influencer fossil hunters are given unlimited budgets and unparalleled media coverage?

Dr. Thomas Carr, a brilliant paleontologist, keeps researching and aiming for funding that will enable him to continue his research work by finding a juvenile T. rex fossil. In a world where actual art and science require developing talents that were not really a necessity in the near past to sustain living off doing what one loves, it’s becoming exhausting trying to find that balance between having the perfect persona and doing the heavy lifting in the background.
On the other hand, Alan Detrich is not an influencer in the modern sense of the word, but he’s an opportunist. To him, everything is a sell, even history, art, and paleontology. It doesn’t matter to him that the fossils of a dinosaur fall into the right hands, as long as those hands can pay him what he thinks he deserves. He affectionately calls one of his T. Rex fossils Z.Rex and shares a tidbit about a bemused billionaire calling it Samson. Instead of scientists getting paid to continue their discoveries and preserve their findings rightfully in natural history museums, monuments and fossils are toyed with in the hands of the Jack Dawsons of the remnants of the Mesozoic Era.
Dr. Carr is what one would expect in a scientist: ascetic, unpretentious, and publicity-shy. He is always in the background, pushing and motivating everyone around him. Dietrich is the stark opposite. He’s a proud American, practicing his right to extend his capitalist empire. He walks with a swagger that screams self-importance and talks about scientific discoveries like selling popcorn at the concession stand. Whereas Dr. Carr identifies every fossil in a carefully curated database, Dietrich stores fossils in huge boxes, calling them bones, assimilated according to how much he’d gain from selling them.
Has everything become for sale? In a synopsis for a new film starring Natalie Portman, a gallery owner sells a work of art with a real corpse attached to it. But that’s expected in the art world; the bizarre and the unbelievable happen every day. How about science, though? Shouldn’t it be more sacred, on a higher pedestal than art? And for those who would argue that art is equally as important. Great, but without solutions for darkness, gravity, fluid dynamics, distance, mass infection, and extreme weather, it’s safe to say that art is allowed to get away with more things that the scientific world shouldn’t have unabashedly commercialized, as we see in this intriguing duel between Dr. Carr and Detrich.
In an ever-shifting world, is there still a place for Dr. Carr and Co.? It’s not just scientists who are asked to boast an online persona if they want to survive the changing times, but also regular shop sellers, teachers, pharmacists, doctors, writers, and the list goes on. The gap between people who influence online and create a brand persona, and those who work silently to achieve their goal has become more gigantic than the Pacific Ocean, in terms of monetary power, financial stability, reach, and visibility. Capitalism ate every crumb and crust on the ground when it comes to hard labor, so that every piece of work now has to get a jab of garnish on top, not only to increase its influential power or funding opportunities, but, alarmingly, just to survive.
It’s only in a place like America that one finds two personas like Dr. Carr and Detrich coexisting in complete harmony despite the differences. It’s both entertaining and shocking when we compare the individual state of each methodologist, each to their own. If The New Extinction succeeds in anything, it’s showing how scientists are crucial to the sustenance of this planet, but the profiteers are the ones leading it.





